Comments on "A Step Forward"
Pages: (1) [ 1 ]
2008-07-23
I mean it
looks like an average race map
plays like an average race map
*is* an average race map
We've fallen into a rut thinking that 'race' only means a set of loopy, semi-automated runs strung together in an obvious fashion.
The problem is, if anyone presents an idea that /isn't/ set to this template, people complain that it's not a race as it doesn't fit to the mean.
Search for my two races (I'm not being narcissistic, I just think they're good examples), lord day has a load and nevermore too. I'm sure there are more, but these will give a good idea of what I'm suggesting.
plays like an average race map
*is* an average race map
We've fallen into a rut thinking that 'race' only means a set of loopy, semi-automated runs strung together in an obvious fashion.
The problem is, if anyone presents an idea that /isn't/ set to this template, people complain that it's not a race as it doesn't fit to the mean.
Search for my two races (I'm not being narcissistic, I just think they're good examples), lord day has a load and nevermore too. I'm sure there are more, but these will give a good idea of what I'm suggesting.
2008-07-23
4/5
Good tilset and good beginning
2008-07-23
When you say obvious
You mean it looks like a race map?
2008-07-23
It's another
obvious race map. I don't want to seem like I have some kind of vendetta, I just wish you guys would put more thought into these...
Races don't have to loop all over the place, you know.
Races don't have to loop all over the place, you know.
2008-07-23
whoops sorry
lol
2008-07-23
Prob not domination
I like the tileset, maybe you could do with more mines. I didnt make some good jumps, but I still finished fine. Fine tune the race as you make it (im in no position to be talking since I have never made a race map >.<)
2008-07-23
AGD
fun, and pretty but not really original or exceptional
| Demo Data |
|---|
2008-07-23
It's not very good
But is it like, above average?
2008-07-23
pretty good
and all. i especially liked how it ended when it was ahead, as destiny says. an improvement. the tileset, as well, was pretty dang good. 4/5
Really short. I liked the style of it but you're races are too loopy. Just have a look at destiny's races. You're main problem is positionings. The flow was very nice, apart from one or two things that could have been done better. But your enemy positioning and gold positioning isn't very good. Keep trying.
| Demo Data |
|---|
2008-07-23
Sub-700
:D Also on NReality if this demo isnt working. You still have to step it up a notch, Flag and daman's races were long and fun, still, good, 4/5.
| Demo Data |
|---|
da_man894
3/5
it was ok though.